Forget superficial-level security. Get into the depths of encrypted connection with SSH Tunnels and VPNs. These are not just privacy tools: They constitute your personal fortresses in the digital world. But which has the crown? Escape the notion surrounding SSH Tunneling, juxtapose it with the gargantuan VPN, and ascertain which technology really deserves its place in your privacy arsenal.
What is SSH Tunneling and How Does It Work
Imagine a secret passage, a digital wormhole, drilling through the internet’s rigid architecture. That’s SSH tunneling, smuggling connections inside an SSH-secured shell to remote networks. Think of directing SSH’s power of remote command execution away from the running of scripts and into the rarefied air of moving precious IP packets to destinations unseen by direct-route means.
Imagine an impregnable digital vault: this method encrypts all data in sturdy armor before it goes onto the rambunctious streets of the Internet. Suddenly, these protocol-based whispers, like HTTP or IRC chatter, stand guilty-eyed under the scrutiny of Man-in-the-Middle attacks. Data secured, transit secured.
Visualize for a minute that you changed your laptop into a secret portal. SSH tunneling allows you to bring in remote network resources in your local set.
Want to peek at a web server hiding behind a firewall?ssh -L 8080:localhost:80 mycoolwebsite.topis your magic incantation. Suddenly, the website running at “mycoolwebsite.top” will open on your browser throughlocalhost:8080. It’s like having an invisible secure wormhole straight to that server.
If you want to get the word out very quickly and securely without creating hundreds of holes through your firewall? then ssh tunneling would be your answer.
Want to conceal your digital self? The SSH tunnels are the way to go! Working its magic with the-Dflag will turn your SSH server into a SOCKS proxy. Now, trying to access a website means doing so from another location. For me, this gold is when I am on-the-go and desire the comfort of my home network’s digital footprint.
Good to know: learn what makes a proxy different from a VPN.
The Difference Between SSH Tunnels and VPNs
Forget VPNs for a second. Let’s see how SSH Tunnels go head-to-head.
Scope
Think of every tunnel as a single thread-connecting you with one destination and one port at a time. So, making a quick detour via a secure server is all under control with one tunnel. Trying to organize your daily commute on these single-lane highways will bring chaos. Wanting to shield your IRC conversation and browsing at the same time means another SSH connection for 6667 and one for 443-a tangled maze of tunnels that simply won’t work.
You can think about a VPN as a cloaking device for your computer. When activated, it reroutesallof your internet traffic through a secret tunnel. No need to tweak any network settings-just a single click on the VPN software for the launch of your privacy, and everything you do online is instantly shielded.
Transport Layer Protocol Support
SSH tunnels: a TCP-only club. Want to reroute your Mumble chatter or Minecraft mayhem through a secure tunnel? Forget about it. SSH’s TCP limitation slams the door on UDP-based applications, leaving your VoIP and gaming traffic stranded.
If you want to divert Minecraft madness or Mumble talks over a secured tunnel, think again. The TCP-only attitude of SSH shuts the gates on UDP applications-wrecking all hopes for your VoIP and gaming traffics!
VPNs? The Swiss Army knives of internet security. Unlike the one-trick pony SSH tunnel, almost all VPN daemons handle both TCP and UDP traffic with consummate skill. This kind of flexibility almost guarantees that they can adjust to almost any real-life network condition, which gives them a big advantage in terms of versatility.
Ease of Use
SSH tunnels are like secret passages where the data can go through, very easy to build. You simply need an SSH client, a server, and an amount of curiosity to get going. What could anybody with even the simplest of thinking could do against network security is not even in question here.
Building a VPN is quite similar to constructing a secret underground tunnel, more complex than simply building an SSH shortcut. I’m talking of configuring network interfaces, exchanging keys for encryption: if we talk about variants such as mesh VPNs using Tinc. Are you intimidated? Don’t worry. You just have to avail yourself of a ready-made VPN and let someone else do all the hard work.
Related : Find out the differences between Wireguard and OpenVPN and which one you should use.
Overall Throughput
Forget sluggish speeds, people! Being neck-to-neck in terms of raw throughput with the best VPNs! My speed test revealed the SSH tunnel blasting at 93 Mbits/sec, while Tailscale VPN was not too far behind at 89 Mbits/sec.
But hold on! Your blazing-fast connection might be experiencing bottlenecking. Think of it like this – your internet speed is a superhighway, and the server’s connection is a one-lane bridge. Even with a gigabit connection, being limited to 100 Mbit/sec on a server would mean crawling.
My test lab? An Amazon EC2 instance, having a pathetic bottleneck of ~100 Mbits/sec. The silver lining? It has a public IPv4 address, allowing for an easy bare-metal level of direct access without any NAT level gymnastics to mask it.
Also , learn about the differences between VPN and a Firewall.
SSH Tunnels vs VPNs: When Should I Use One?
SSH tunnels and VPNs: ultimately, the choice hinges on your machine’s purpose and the task at hand.
Need instant network privacy? The SSH tunnels will be your ace in the hole. While most UNIX systems come with them pre-installed, one can generate secure connections between machines faster than one can say “terminal command.” Think of them as digital wormholes, perfect for creating blink-and-you’ll-miss-it secure links.
Tired of fading privacy fixes? Foremost in network protection stand VPNs. The proverbial Swiss Army knives of online security, they afford flexibility unparalleled, support a varied set of protocols, and scale to accommodate your needs, whether you’re a lone wolf or a budding pack. Now, some elbow grease is needed with the initial setup, but the payback: a lifetime of unshakable peace of mind.
SSH tunnels vs. VPNs, that’s been said often enough! Unleash the true power of SSH! Dive into LostInThought’s ultimate SSH pipe guide for Linux and sail away from the mainstream knowledge.
Image credit: Dan Nelson via Unsplash. All alterations and screenshots by Ramces Red.
Thanks for reading Is SSH Tunneling Better Than Using a VPN?
